Question 1: What are Hari
Singh’s reactions to the prospect of receiving an education? Do they change
over time? What makes him return to Anil?
Answer: Hari Singh’s
reactions to the prospect of receiving an education change over time. When he
started living with Anil he wanted to be literate so that he could become a
more cunning cheat. Later on there is a change in his heart. He wants to earn
respect in life. Probably he is influenced by the calm in Anil’s life.
Although, both of them depend on irregular sources of income, but Anil seems to
be more satisfied. Hari Singh develops a desire to be part of the civilized
society.
Question 2: Why does not Anil
hand the thief over to the police? Do you think most people would have done so?
In what ways is Anil different from such employers?
Answer: The wetness of notes
must have given the idea of Hari Singh’s act to Anil. But Anil is pleased with
the fact that Hari returned whatever he had stolen. This must have given him a
hope for Hari Singh’s desire to change. That is why he did not hand over Hari
to police. People like Anil are hard to find. Most people would have reacted in
predictable ways by thrashing Hari Singh and calling police. Anil is different
because he wants his servant to become literate. He wants his servant to lead a
respectable life in future.
Question 3: Do you think
people like Anil and Hari Singh are found only in fiction, or are there such
people in real life?
Answer: Both Anil and Hari
Singh are rare in society. Especially the changed Hari Singh after he decides
to go back to Anil is difficult to find.
Question 4: Do you think it a
significant detail in the story that Anil is a struggling writer? Does this
explain his behaviour in any way?
Answer: Hari Singh’s
observation about Anil getting irregular income and Anil’s statement about his
sale of a book to a publisher indicates that he is a struggling writer. He
lives life according to the flow of money he gets at a given time. When he gets
the money he enjoys eating out with his friends. When he is having less money
then he even doesn’t accept paying salary to Hari Singh.
Question 5: Have you met
anyone like Hari Singh? Can you think and imagine the circumstances that can
turn a fifteen-year-old boy into a thief?
Answer: I have met several
people who help needy people and help them specially in becoming literate.
Fifteenth year is a very dangerous phase of life as it is teenage. A deep scar
on mind or a deep sense of greed can make criminal out of ordinary boys and
girls. There is a chance of Hari Singh getting a sound rebuke from his parents
for asking some costly thing. Or there is equal chance of Hari Singh spoiling
his consumption pattern beyond his means.
Question 6: Where is the
story set? Which language or languages are spoken in these places? Do you think
the characters in the story spoke to each other in English?
Answer: The story is set in
Uttar Pradesh somewhere near Lucknow. The town is having an important railway
station as express trains have stoppage over there. The presence of sweet shop
indicates towards presence of a decent market. The description of hotels near
railway station indicates that it is an important centre where people come from
far off places for business related activities.